Friday, September 30, 2011

Kindle-ing Competition


We don’t think of the Kindle Fire as a tablet. We think of it as a service.

– Jeff Bezos

The analysts predicted that Amazon would introduce its new Kindle Fire tablet today with an aggressive low price of $250 to $300, in line with low margin competitors like Samsung.

They were wrong. Amazon priced it at $199, with some versions of the Kindle selling for as little as $79.

How can Amazon afford to price it so low? Is their manufacturing and supply chain that much more efficient than Samsung, RIM and Apple? In a word, no. They key is the increasingly important economics of two-sided networks and information complements, as analyzed in the seminal work of Geoff Parker and Marshall van Alstyne.

Amazon isn’t simply selling a device, it’s selling a portal into a cornucopia of books, music, movies and other media, all available a click away at Amazon. Kindle owners trust Amazon with their credit cards, and with an easy and enticing user interface that directs users to Amazon media, recommendations that are eerily accurate, and virtually instant delivery, it’s hard for infovores to resist spending far more via the Kindle than they ever did via the web. Believe me, I know from personal experience.

Of course, Amazon knows this and makes a healthy, but not unreasonable, margin on every media sale. What’s more, they avoid having to pay 30% commission that Apple extracts when Amazon sells ebooks via the iPad. Because the profit stream from Amazon’s media products is boosted every time another customer buys a Kindle, Amazon can afford to price it at very low, or even negative margins. That gives them an advantage over standalone competitors. What’s more, Amazon can skimp on memory in the Kindle Fire—only 8 gigabytes – because owners can store an infinite number of books, songs, movies and documents on Amazon’s cloud servers at no cost. They even throw in a 30 day trial of Amazon Prime, the two-day delivery program that boosts loyalty among customers of Amazons non-digital goods.

The battle of the tablets is not a battle of devices, but a battle of ecosystems. Jeff Bezos and his team at Amazon have learned well the lessons of two-sided markets.

Tuesday, September 27, 2011

The Dismal Economics of Moneyball


Moneyball is a huge hit, which doesn’t happen too often to movies featuring an economics major who’s good at statistics. It tells the true story of how the Oakland A’s became a competitive team despite having a payroll less than 1/3 of the Yankees. They did it by using statistical techniques pioneered by sabermetrician Bill James and applied by Harvard economics grad Paul DePodesta. For instance, old school baseball scouts undervalued the simple talent of getting on base via walks. That’s not very exciting, but a team the does it over and over tends to win more than its competitors. By combing through the data to find undervalued traits like drawing walks, the Oakland A’s were able to find talented players without spending a lot of money.

To an economist, that’s a story not only about the power of information, but also the importance of innovation in creating competitive advantage. Oakland’s General Manager, Billy Beane, didn’t compete the same way as all the other teams, he did something new and different, and that gave the A’s an edge.

However, that’ s not the end of the story. Competition leads others to match that innovation, and over time, the excess returns are competed away. Oakland’s competitive secret didn’t not remain a secret for long. In 2003, when Michael Lewis's book Moneyball was published, the Boston Red Sox hired Bill James to advise them, and apply analytic techniques to optimize their much larger payroll. They promptly won the World Series the next year, and again in 2007. Today there are whole conferences, like the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference devoted to these techniques. So does Moneyball still provide an edge?

According to an academic study by Jahn Hakes and Raymond Sauer:

….certain baseball skills were valued inefficiently [in 1999-2002] and this inefficiency was profitably exploited by managers with the ability to generate and interpret statistical knowledge. Consistent with Lewis’s story and economic reasoning, as knowledge of the inefficiency became increasingly dispersed across baseball teams the market corrected the original mispricing.

Sadly, the insights Bill James identified no longer provide a measurable advantage. This year, Oakland will finish with another losing season. And my beloved Red Sox? They lost their lead in the wildcard race tonight and may not make the playoffs. Time to hunt for the next big innovation.

Monday, September 12, 2011

Is Koomey's Law eclipsing Moore's law?


Most people are familiar with Moore's Law, the doubling of computer power roughly every 18 months. But as technology becomes more mobile "Koomey's Law" may be more relevant to consumers. Dr. Jon Koomey and his colleagues recently completed a study showing that energy consumption for computing is improving just as fast as processing power. At left, is a chart from a their paper "Implications of Historical Trends in the Electrical Efficiency of Computing". The paper is highlighted in the latest issue of MIT's Technology Review, where Dr. Koomey explains:

"The idea is that at a fixed computing load, the amount of battery you need will fall by a factor of two every year and a half," says Jonathan Koomey, consulting professor of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford University and lead author of the study. More mobile computing and sensing applications become possible, Koomey says, as energy efficiency continues its steady improvement.

The battery size and battery life of an iPad or Android phone is one of the biggest design constraints. Furthermore, in the next five years, we may see a trillion small computing devices blanket the planet as the Internet of Things awakens. Understanding Koomey's Law will be the key to making this possible. Progress is happening on many different fronts.

Sunday, September 11, 2011

What CAN'T computers do?

Not too long ago, there was a relatively long list of things machines couldn't do by themselves: play chess, read legal briefs, translate poetry, vacuum floors, drive cars, etc. But that list is getting shorter and shorter every year. The latest casualty may be writing newspaper articles.

Kris Hammond and Larry Birnbaum at Northwestern's Intelligent Information Laboratory have started a company called Narrative Science which does just that. Here's a sample, produced with 60 seconds of the end of the third quarter of a recent football game:

“WISCONSIN appears to be in the driver’s seat en route to a win, as it leads 51-10 after the third quarter. Wisconsin added to its lead when Russell Wilson found Jacob Pedersen for an eight-yard touchdown to make the score 44-3 ... . ”

According to Steve Lohr, in the New York Times:

The Narrative Science software can make inferences based on the historical data it collects and the sequence and outcomes of past games. To generate story “angles,” explains Mr. Hammond of Narrative Science, the software learns concepts for articles like “individual effort,” “team effort,” “come from behind,” “back and forth,” “season high,” “player’s streak” and “rankings for team.” Then the software decides what element is most important for that game, and it becomes the lead of the article, he said. The data also determines vocabulary selection. A lopsided score may well be termed a “rout” rather than a “win.”

He ends his article with a prediction by Dr. Hammond:

“In five years,” he says, “a computer program will win a Pulitzer Prize — and I’ll be damned if it’s not our technology.”

That may be a bit ambitious, but one nearly-certain prediction is that computer power will increase by roughly 10-fold in the next five years, and by 100-fold within a decade.

You can also be sure that journalism won't be the only job affected.

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

Steve Jobs Tells Three Stories about his Life


Thanks, Steve, for all you've done for the world. You've been living a life true to your ideals

Monday, August 22, 2011

Good Taxes and Bad Taxes

Congress is considering increasing payroll taxes.

Congress is also considering cutting gasoline taxes.

The net effect is that we would tax work and employment more, while taxing congestion and pollution less.

This is the opposite of what most economists recommend. Arthur Pigou showed that we should tax things we want to reduce, not things we want to increase. What's more, increasing taxes on employment in the midst of the biggest slump since the 1930s is especially foolish.

Perhaps if enough citizens contact Congress, they will do the right thing.







Saturday, June 25, 2011

Can Digital Technologies Replace Superstars?

Japan's newest pop star, Aimi Eguchi, is a digital creation.



For the past couple of decades, digital technologies have been responsible for skill biased technical change, automating and replacing routine, low-skill work while augmenting the demand for more skilled workers. Bank tellers, clerks and assembly line workers were early targets of automation, while rock stars and CEOs benefited from being able to scale their efforts.

The incomes of superstars have skyrocketed while median wages have stagnated.


However, there's nothing inevitable about technologies only being used to replace low-wage work. Pop stars, actors, artists, writers, mathematicians, chess grandmasters have all been targets of automation. In many ways, expert knowledge is easier to codify than common sense. In principle, every profession is potentially vulnerable as digital technologies, robotics and artificial intelligence advance.

There will be increasing disruption in the economy as businesses restructure, and employment, wages, and incomes re-align to the new reality.

Which sectors do you think will be most affected in the next 10 years. Which professions, other than b-school professors, are relatively immune for the time being?

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Google is putting the "auto" into automobile.


If the last big revolution was replacing muscle power with machines, the next one is automating and augmenting more mental tasks. Henry Ford and compatriots replaced the horse, now Google is working to replace the driver.

According to John Markoff in the New York Times, their self-driving cars have now logged over 140,000 miles on California roads, including highway 1 between L.A. and San Francisco. They are now lobbying Nevada to allow these cars on public roads.

The project leader, Dr. Sebastian Thrun has argued that robotic vehicles would increase energy efficiency, reduce road injuries and deaths, and cut the number of cars needed in the United States in half.

“What if I could take out my phone and say, ‘Zipcar, come here,’ ” he asked an industry conference last year, “and a moment later the Zipcar came around the


I suspect the biggest barrier to the adoption of self-driving cars is not technological -- these videos show how the systems are rapidly progressing. Instead, the impediments will be regulatory and cultural. There are about 40,000 deaths on the America's roads each year with our human drivers. But suppose the robotic cars were 100 times safer. That would still be 400 deaths per year. Can you imagine the public outcry, no to mention the legal judgments, that would follow the first time a human was killed due to an error by a robotic car? Will they have to be 100% perfect before the are adopted?

Monday, May 9, 2011

Business class vs. Economy online news

Newspapers like the New York Times and Wall Street Journal are currently experimenting with paywalls that prevent non-paying customers from accessing some content. But what if all customers could access the same content, but the "economy" (i.e. free) visitors saw ads and other clutter while the "business class" customers got a cleaner experience? Would that be a viable model?

Oliver Reichenstein argues that it could be, and gives the example of the two pages below. Would you pay a premium to read the one on the right? What else could a publisher do to create premium experience for paying customers, other than restricting content?


Wednesday, May 4, 2011

Inequality is growing around the world

A new OECD reports concludes that "inequality is on the rise in most OECD countries" and that:

In a large majority of OECD countries, household incomes of the top 10% grew faster than those of the poorest 10%, leading to widening income inequality. Differences in the pace of income growth across household groups were particularly pronounced in some of the English-speaking countries, some of the Nordic countries and Israel. In Israel and Japan, real incomes of people at the bottom of the income ladder actually have fallen since the mid-1980s.


As The Economist summarizes that data as follows:

American society is more unequal than those in most other OECD countries, and growth in inequality there has been relatively large. But with very few exceptions, the rich have done better over the past 30 years, even in highly egalitarian places like Scandinavia.


Technology and globalization are likely the primary causes of the recent changes, although the institutions, culture and government policies can also make a difference.

Here's a chart from the Economist, HT: Greg Mankiw